Did you know that the size of a spice tin can have a significant impact? Big spice companies like McCormick & Co. are facing lawsuits because of the size of their ground pepper tins.
Watkins Inc., a small company, claims that McCormick reduced the amount of pepper in their tins by 25% while keeping the tin size unchanged. This means you’re actually getting less pepper despite the appearance of the tin being the same.
Why does this matter? It’s about fairness and transparency. Watkins argues that McCormick is deceiving consumers by making them believe they’re getting more pepper than they actually are. McCormick’s tins are opaque, so you can’t see how much pepper is inside, unlike Watkins, which offers smaller tins with the same amount of pepper.

Watkins accuses McCormick of using deceptive packaging tactics to make their product seem superior. Despite McCormick’s tins claiming to contain 6 ounces of pepper, the text is small and difficult to read.
This practice, known as “slack-filling,” is considered dishonest and violates consumer protection regulations. McCormick is not providing customers with the amount of pepper they expect by not filling their tins completely. This not only affects the value for money but also makes it challenging to make accurate product comparisons.
Next time you’re shopping for spices, take a close look at the packaging. Don’t be swayed by the size of the tin—what matters is what’s inside!