Nicholas Wallace delivered one of the eeriest magic performances ever seen on *America’s Got Talent* when he stepped onto the stage during Season 14 in 2019. Instead of relying on flashy illusions, Wallace created an unsettling atmosphere involving a mysterious rocking chair, a creepy doll, and judge Gabrielle Union. From the opening moments, the performance felt less like traditional magic and more like a chilling supernatural story.
Wallace began by telling the audience about a supposedly haunted rocking chair connected to strange deaths at a hotel. He then invited Gabrielle Union to participate, asking her to sit in the chair. To make the experience even more mysterious, Union was blindfolded, leaving her unable to see what Wallace was doing. The setup immediately captured the attention of the judges and the audience.
The most shocking part came when Wallace introduced the unsettling doll. Standing away from Union, he manipulated the doll while instructing the blindfolded judge to respond whenever she felt a sensation. As Wallace moved the doll’s arm, Union’s arm appeared to move at the same time. He continued the routine with other movements, creating the disturbing impression that the doll and Union were somehow connected.
What made the performance especially effective was Wallace’s storytelling and restraint. Rather than overwhelming the audience with complicated props, he allowed suspense and imagination to do much of the work. The judges were visibly confused by what they had witnessed, while Union was left trying to understand the strange sensations she had experienced while blindfolded. Her reaction added another layer of authenticity and unease to the performance.
Wallace ultimately received enough support from the judges to move forward to the Judge Cuts, proving that his unusual combination of magic, storytelling, and horror had made a memorable impression. His audition remains one of the more unusual performances from *America’s Got Talent* Season 14, largely because it blurred the line between illusion and something that seemed genuinely paranormal. For viewers who enjoy creepy magic and unexplained performances, Wallace’s audition remains difficult to forget.
Watch the full video here: